Grand Theft America

Daily brief ·

The worst case for Tuesday is federal agents taking ballots. Courts have stopped most of what came before.

What’s new
On October 23, The Economist’s Checks and Balance walked through how Trump could interfere with the midterms: before the vote, on Election Day, and when the House is seated on January 3. The panel’s read: the worst cases are possible but unlikely, and the administration has lost almost every legal fight so far. Voters aren’t waiting. Early ballots hit a midterm record of nearly 48 million by October 30, per the University of Florida Election Lab.
Why it matters
The scenario election experts fear most, Economist correspondent Kennett Werner said, is federal agents seizing ballots on Election Day. That breaks the chain of custody, so nobody could say who won, and the result might not be certifiable. It has never happened during a live election in modern times. But the FBI has already carted off Fulton County’s 2020 ballots, more than 600 boxes, and a judge let it keep them.
Before the vote
  • The fraud numbers fell apart. DHS said 16,000 noncitizens were on Nevada’s rolls, then cut it to 185. Nevada checked all 185. Every one was a citizen.
  • The California hold failed. DOJ asked a court to stop California counting about 20,000 mail ballots. The 9th Circuit refused, 2-1, on October 30.
  • Mail voting survived. The Supreme Court refused, 7-2, to let the Postal Service’s ballot rule take effect for this election.
  • The people who guard the machines were cut. DHS appointees asked the federal election-security agency, CISA, to secretly buy a voting machine, hack it and send the findings to the White House, ProPublica reported. It never happened, partly because the agents who could do it had just been laid off. CISA has lost about a third of its staff.
On Election Day
  • ICE at the polls. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said ICE would go to polling places for “threats” or to serve warrants. Federal law bars armed federal officers at the polls. DHS now says ICE “is not planning operations targeting polling locations,” and a judge ordered DHS to hand over its plans.
  • Troops. Gen. Dan Caine wrote to Sen. Elissa Slotkin that the military has “no plans” to send troops to polling places or “to seize ballots, voting machines or other election-related material,” AP reported. The law’s one exception lets troops come “to repel armed enemies of the United States.” The panel’s fear is a claimed threat from Venezuela, Cuba or Iran used as the excuse.
  • Monitors. DOJ is sending about 1,000 election monitors and won’t name the sites until Tuesday. At Wyoming’s August primary, two of them asked to examine the tabulators. The county clerk said no, and the state’s Republican governor called it “irregular.”
After the vote
Columnist James Bennet’s bigger worry is the House. Election deniers now hold statewide office in about 20 states, he said, and could send up disputed certifications to delay seating members on January 3. Norm Eisen of the Democracy Defenders Fund said the administration has stretched court orders in more than 300 cases but has always complied in the end.
What to watch
How fast judges move if anything is seized. Washington bureau chief Shashank Joshi’s point: the administration acts first and loses in court later, and the damage is done in between. Eisen said litigators are ready for up to 126 cases. Three Los Angeles County election workers are due before a federal grand jury on November 4.

More daily briefs