Power Grab/Point the law at critics
Federal agents seized an immigration lawyer’s phone after his know-your-rights videos, and a judge says it was likely retaliation
— Federal agents seize an immigration lawyer's phone after his know-your-rights videos; a judge finds likely retaliation.
Andrew Lattarulo’s phone was copied at Boston’s airport in September 2025. On November 13, 2026, a federal judge found he is likely to prove the seizure punished his speech.
What happened
On September 28, 2025, three Customs and Border Protection agents and a Homeland Security Investigations officer stopped Andrew Lattarulo as he got off a flight from Aruba at Logan Airport. They seized his phone without a warrant and downloaded a full copy, including privileged messages with his clients, the court’s opinion says. The phone came back eight days later.
Lattarulo runs an Instagram account of know-your-rights videos on immigration. The government tied the seizure to an HSI inquiry into whether his firm had employed people without work authorization. The firm’s partner in charge of hiring paperwork took the same trip and came home a day earlier without being stopped.
Where it stands
On November 13, 2026, Judge Allison Burroughs found Lattarulo is likely to prove the seizure was retaliation for his speech. Phone searches are not shown to be a usual step in that kind of employment inquiry, she wrote, and the government “elected to adopt a highly unusual investigative method that appears designed to inflict a maximal burden on Lattarulo.” She ordered the copy kept unreadable until the case ends and did not rule on his Fourth Amendment claim.
The government says it has more evidence supporting the search but will not disclose it while the investigation is open, Newsweek reported. No charges have been reported against Lattarulo or his firm.
Who benefited
Homeland Security, which holds a full copy of a critic’s phone and wants permission to search it. It says it would use a separate team to screen out privileged material.
Who wanted something
Homeland Security Investigations, which seized the phone three days after notifying the firm of suspect documents, inside the 10-day window its own policy gives employers to fix them. The judge wrote that this “aggressive deviation from protocol strongly suggests” the seizure did not come from an ordinary investigative motive.
Who lost out
Lattarulo, and the immigrants he represents, whose confidential messages with their lawyer sit in a government copy. The judge declined to order the copy destroyed for now.
Why it matters
A lawyer who tells immigrants their rights had his whole phone copied at the border, and a judge says the likely reason was what he said. Every immigration lawyer who speaks publicly now knows the airport can be where it happens. In March, prosecutors subpoenaed X and Reddit to unmask anonymous ICE critics.
Sources U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts (primary)NewsweekReason (The Volokh Conspiracy)
- ReceiptTrump signs NSPM-7, directing Joint Terrorism Task Forces at funders, nonprofits and tax-exempt groups using ideological markersSame group: Investigate civil society and nonprofits
- ReceiptThe Justice Department told prosecutors in at least seven states to prepare investigations of George Soros’s Open Society FoundationsSame group: Investigate civil society and nonprofits
- ReceiptBondi’s Justice Department got Apple and Facebook to pull an ICE-watch app and group, and a court has now barred it for goodSame group: Investigate civil society and nonprofits
- BriefFive Tried-and-True Moves to Capture a Democracy and Make a KillingFive moves to capture a democracy