Grand Theft America

Power Grab/Point the law at critics

The Justice Department charges James Comey a third time, over a 2016 leak, 10 years to the day later

— The Justice Department charges James Comey a third time, over a 2016 leak, 10 years to the day later.

Prosecutors filed the charge in secret on the last day of the 10-year window, without a grand jury. Comey’s lawyers say two U.S. attorneys had already declined the case.

Filed
October 5, 2026 (under seal); unsealed October 26, 2026
Court
U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, No. 1:26-cr-00229, Judge Trevor McFadden
Charges
Transmitting national defense information; conspiracy (18 U.S.C. § 793)
Alleged conduct
October 5, 2016
Status
Underway (ruling on dismissal deferred; grand jury pending)

What happened

On October 5, 2026, prosecutors filed a two-count criminal information against former FBI Director James Comey. An information is a charge filed by prosecutors without a grand jury vote. It accuses him of transmitting national defense information to a person not entitled to receive it on October 5, 2016, while he led the FBI, and of conspiring with “others known and unknown” to do so.

Comey’s lawyers say the charge concerns a disclosure to the New York Times for an article published that day. DOJ asked Judge Trevor McFadden to seal the case, citing unnamed co-conspirators and ongoing investigations, and he did.

On October 26, at Comey’s request and with DOJ not opposing, McFadden unsealed it.

Where it stands

Comey moved to dismiss on October 9, arguing that the 10-year limit for bringing an indictment had run and that the sealed information was filed to stop the clock. His lawyers say the disclosure “was investigated by two separate U.S. Attorneys over the past ten years. Both declined to prosecute.” Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald said “Mr. Comey steadfastly maintains his innocence.”

At an October 30 hearing, McFadden put off ruling so the department could pursue an indictment. A prosecutor told him evidence was being presented to a grand jury and said, “They may indict, they may not indict,” the Associated Press reported. McFadden said he would be “extremely frustrated if there’s some sort of dawn raid” to arrest Comey; the prosecutor said, “That’s not going to happen.” A transcript of a sealed October 9 hearing shows a prosecutor told McFadden the department had considered treating The New York Times as a co-conspirator, The Times reported on November 8, Quartz noted. No indictment had been reported as of November 19, 2026.

Who benefited

Prosecutors kept a 10-year-old allegation alive by filing on the last day it could be charged. Filing under seal kept the charge out of public view for three weeks.

Who wanted something

Trump fired Comey in 2017, and the two have attacked each other since. DOJ’s first case against Comey, for false statements, was dismissed in November 2025 because the prosecutor had been invalidly appointed. A second, over an “86 47” seashell photo, is pending in North Carolina, where he has moved to dismiss.

Who lost out

Comey, who now faces a third federal criminal case in just over a year. “They’re back, again,” he said in a video.

Why it matters

The same Justice Department has now charged the same Trump critic three times, the latest over conduct that two earlier U.S. attorneys reviewed and did not prosecute, according to his lawyers. The charge is unproven; a judge will decide whether it was filed in time.

Sources U.S. District Court, D.D.C. (primary)CNBCThe Washington PostABC NewsAssociated Press (via WBAL)Quartz (on The New York Times)

More on this