Power Grab/Make it too expensive to hold him accountable
DOJ demanded 18 months of records on everyone a group of reporters messaged on LinkedIn, and an appeals court called it overbroad
— DOJ demands 18 months of reporters' LinkedIn records; an appeals court calls the order overbroad.
In a leak investigation, the Justice Department got secret orders for the journalists’ LinkedIn contacts and a one-year gag on the company. On November 10, 2026, the 4th Circuit sent the orders back to be narrowed.
What happened
In a national-security leak investigation, the Justice Department obtained two court orders against LinkedIn under the Stored Communications Act. The investigation concerns an article that revealed details of “a top-secret United States military operation in a foreign country,” according to the 4th Circuit’s opinion. The first order required LinkedIn to produce 18 months of metadata identifying every user a group of journalists at an unnamed outlet had corresponded with on the platform. The second barred LinkedIn from telling anyone, including the journalists and their employer, for one year.
In those 18 months the journalists published nearly 1,000 articles, the court found, and less than 5% appear to have anything to do with the leak. Many of the people the records would identify “have no conceivable relationship to the leak investigation,” it wrote; they are affiliated with media outlets, universities and law firms connected to other stories. A magistrate judge and a district judge in Newport News, Virginia, had approved the orders and refused LinkedIn’s request to narrow them.
Where it stands
On November 10, 2026, a unanimous 4th Circuit panel ruled the orders “substantially overbroad” and sent the case back to be narrowed. “A request by the government to scoop up reporters’ records wholesale and ascertain the identity of their sources would tip the balance against informed discourse in a manner inimical to democratic health,” Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson III, a Reagan appointee, wrote, AP reported. Unless the government gives a better reason, LinkedIn must be allowed to tell one vetted lawyer for the outlet. The court rejected LinkedIn’s bid to quash the orders entirely and let the government keep its secret filings from the company.
The ruling does not name the outlet or the article. Its details raised the possibility that it involves a known leak inquiry into a New York Times article on a botched 2019 military operation in North Korea, the Times reported.
Who benefited
The Justice Department, which got the orders approved in secret and would have learned every source the reporters reached on LinkedIn over 18 months. The appeals court left it room to seek a narrower set of records.
Who wanted something
The Trump administration, which defended the orders on appeal, Politico reported. The court called the investigation “understandably vigorous” given the national-security stakes.
Who lost out
Reporters and the people who talk to them, including sources on stories that had nothing to do with the leak. LinkedIn was ordered to stay silent, so the journalists could not object to the demand themselves.
Why it matters
A reporter’s contact list is a list of sources. Once the government holds it, people who talked to the press about anything are exposed. In July, prosecutors subpoenaed the phone records of New York Times reporters’ relatives, and in January the FBI searched a Washington Post reporter’s home in another leak case.
Sources U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit (primary)PoliticoAPThe New York Times
- ReceiptWhite House gives Politico 48 hours to retract 3 stories or face “consequences”Same group: Punish critical news coverage
- ReceiptThe Justice Department opened an antitrust investigation into 5 TV networks for pausing their coverage of Trump.Same group: Punish critical news coverage
- ReceiptThe White House bans CNN, MS NOW and Politico, and a judge restores their access within 5 daysSame group: Punish critical news coverage
- BriefWho Stood Up to Trump, and Who FoldedWho stood up to him, and who folded